Owning something beautiful can come at a cost. A priceless piece of art, a literary estate, or a collection of antique silverware can transform its owner into a custodian of cultural capital for the next generation, and that responsibility carries real risk.

Unsure who truly owns the Rubens on the wall? Doubt its authenticity? Wonder whether it was already gifted to another family member? Or are you in dispute over a sale, an inheritance, or art held in trust? We can help.

How our art and cultural property dispute solicitors can help

We advise on the full range of art and cultural property disputes, including:

  • Ownership disputes
  • Disputes over authenticity or provenance
  • Art valuation disputes
  • Inheritance and estate disputes involving artwork
  • Trust disputes involving art collections
  • Disputes between beneficiaries, executors or trustees
  • Claims involving galleries, dealers, agents or auction houses
  • Sale or transfer disputes
  • Restitution claims
  • Negligence claims involving professional advisers or valuer
  • Copyright protection and licensing

 


Common types of art and cultural property disputes

  • Ownership disputes

Who actually owns the piece of art? These disputes often follow a joint purchase, inheritance, separation or a loan, complicated by potentially incomplete paperwork, and involving artworks that have passed through many hands.

  • Authenticity and provenance disputes

Is the artwork genuine, and can its history be adequately proven? These cases often turn on expert evidence, scientific testing and documentary research.

  • Inheritance disputes involving art

Art collections are a common pressure point for families in estate disputes, and they may include disagreements over specific pieces, allegations that artworks have been gifted prior to death, and concerns about how an executor has handled an art collection.

  • Court of protection disputes involving collections of artwork

If someone loses capacity, disputes may arise in relation to the contents of their home, including priceless collections of art, whether pieces should be sold, and how they should be stored.

  • Valuation disputes

As each piece of artwork is unique, it can be difficult to price, so valuers often disagree. Such disagreements can be seen in probate disputes, Court of Protection disputes, divorce, and wherever collections are divided.

  • Disputes with galleries, dealers or auction houses

Disputes can arise with auction houses over unauthorised sales, disputed commissions, missing proceeds of sale, and works that have not been returned after consignments.

  • Trust and estate art collection disputes

Trustees and beneficiaries can fall out over how art held in trust is managed, insured, stored or sold, and whether trustees are exercising their powers properly.

  • Cultural property and restitution disputes

Antiquities, archaeological material, manuscripts and literary archives also involve questions around title, export and repatriation, particularly where an object’s history crosses borders, or involves a claim that it was looted, or wrongfully removed from its country of origin.


Who we help

Private collectors

Beneficiaries

Executors and administrators

Trustees

High-net-worth individuals and families

Galleries and art professionals

Individuals involved in estate or trust disputes

People concerned about ownership, valuation or sale of artwork

Facing an art dispute involving ownership, authenticity, provenance or inheritance? Contact us for expert legal advice.

Why Choose us?

An art dispute is rarely only about the artwork. Often such disputes sit within a wider inheritance, trust or family wealth dispute, with a prized and often irreplaceable asset at its centre.

We are one of the largest and most experienced private wealth disputes teams in the UK, and we bring our dedication, expertise and pragmatism to art disputes.


How art and cultural property disputes can be resolved?

There is no one size fits all approach. We support clients though:

  • Early assessment of merits and risks
  • Prompt protective steps, to stop a disputed work being sold, moved or exported
  • Negotiation and mediation, where appropriate
  • Obtaining expert evidence – from valuers, art historians, and forensic specialists
  • Taking a case to court where agreement is not possible

 

Key contact

Danielle Cahill

Partner
Danielle Cahill is a Partner in the Private Wealth Disputes team in London, with a particular focus on developing Hugh James’ cross-border and offshore disputes practice. Her expertise lies in representing high-net-worth individuals in complex family disputes, as well as advising trustees, commercial and banking clients.

Next steps

We’re here to get things moving. Drop a message to one of our experts and we’ll get straight back to you.

Call us: 033 3016 2222

Message us

"*" indicates required fields

Name*