20 November 2026 | Comment | Article by Alexander Shah

Why wealth and wellbeing are not mutually exclusive, and why estate planning is a family endeavour


We recently wrote about the latest judgement in the case of Rogers v Wills[1]. In that article, we discussed the need for families to formalise commercial arrangements. The case illustrates something much simpler though: the need for families to approach questions of inheritance and elder care provision together, and why they should document those discussions clearly. It is worth considering how a family might approach a situation like this differently. The key is open communication.

Get in touch

If you’d like to know more information or understand how to have these conversation, contact our Estate Planning team. 

What happened?

For greater detail, you can refer to our earlier article. In brief, Sheila Wills left behind a close and affectionate family of six children. In her later years, Sheila’s children identified a need for informal care and agreed that she would move into her daughter Bernadette’s home. No formal agreement for payment was made. Bernadette’s siblings were aware of the anticipation of compensation, but no action was taken. After Sheila’s death, Bernadette sought compensation, and her siblings disagreed.

Communication – some good, some bad

In this case, the family were initially engaged with each other around the issue of their mother’s care. There was clear agreement that care provision should be compensated. Text messages and other similar modern methods of communication provided a good body of evidence that this was the case.

As disagreement grew, communication rested more heavily on undocumented verbal conversations.

After Sheila’s death, Bernadette transferred funds to herself without first telling her siblings of her intention to do so, or seeking agreement as to the amount.  Accusations and demands for repayment followed. Bernadette was prosecuted for theft but acquitted by a jury. Family relationships were destroyed.

What could have been done differently?

Separate conversations between different family members can leave everyone believing that an arrangement is settled, while understanding it differently.

In this case, we would have advised the family to hold a dedicated family meeting, involving as many people as possible. This would have provided an opportunity to discuss the care required, who would provide it and how it would be funded before expectations became entrenched, and before individuals had an expectation of inheritance.

We would have assisted Sheila in communicating her goals and wishes clearly. We would have talked to the family about the need to ensure that Sheila was receiving the support she needed in later life, and the fact that this might mean her estate would be diminished.

We would also have prepared a memorandum for everyone to sign, setting out:

  • What care would be provided and when payment would start;
  • How payment would be calculated;
  • Whether expenses, accommodation and living costs were included;
  • How often payment would be made; and
  • When the arrangement would be reviewed.

Putting a family agreement in writing is not a sign of mistrust. It is a safeguard for everyone when circumstances change, memories fade or relationships come under strain. It gives appropriate weight to the needs of each generation. Discuss it, document it and review it regularly.

What we suggest, and how we can help

As individuals live longer, and as the economic environment becomes more challenging for younger generations, we recommend that families start holding regular family meetings. The need to do so increases alongside family wealth. Discuss the challenges facing the family, anticipate future needs, and contemplate how everyone’s interests might best be served. Older parents’ needs should be central. Good planning can help families meet those needs while making informed decisions about preserving and passing on wealth.

Our estate planning team can support families with such an exercise and provide an impartial voice with an understanding of different strategies, their legal requirements, and tax consequences. Where appropriate, we can prepare Family Constitutions or Family Covenants, helping to provide a structure for stability and prosperity for all involved.

[1] Rogers v Wills [2026] EWHC 2231 (Ch), [45]

Author bio

Alexander Shah

Senior Associate
Alexander Shah (Alex) is a Senior Associate in our Wills and Estate Planning team, based in the firm’s London office. He advises high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth individuals and families on wills, succession planning and the management of wealth across generations.

Disclaimer: The information on the Hugh James website is for general information only and reflects the position at the date of publication. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be treated as such. If you would like to ensure the commentary reflects current legislation, case law or best practice, please contact the blog author.

 

Next steps

We’re here to get things moving. Drop a message to one of our experts and we’ll get straight back to you.

Call us: 033 3016 2222

Message us

"*" indicates required fields

Name*